• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Adoptee Rights Law Center

Legal representation and advocacy for adoptees

  • Home
  • Latest
  • The OBC
    • Laws
    • Legislation
    • Maps
    • FAQ
  • Citizenship
    • Legislation
  • About
    • Contact

Last updated on May 8, 2019

Texas Has Defied Expectations. Or Has It?

I’m fine admitting I’ve been wrong about things, and so far I’ve been wrong several times about HB2725, the Texas bill that in its current form would provide an unrestricted right for adult adoptees to get their own original birth certificates.

I thought the bill, as drafted and introduced, died in committee after failing to get enough favorable votes. In fact, I was called an arrogant buffoon at the time for stating that the bill, as written, was dead. But the bill came back for a second life, exhumed from the committee at the last minute on an unusual second vote. The committee met hastily this past Monday night to vote the bill out of committee, just hours before deadline, though five members were absent.

I then thought there was no chance that the bill would, literally with less than two hours to spare, be reported out of a second committee, resulting in it being placed on the House floor calendar. Wrong again. It was. It’s now on the House floor calendar for second reading and eligible for a vote this Thursday, along with nearly 100 other bills fighting to be considered before a midnight deadline.

I thought, since discriminatory amendments had been presented and made a condition of passage—and since Governor Greg Abbott, an adoptive father, had already signaled he would veto HB2725 as it was currently written—there was no chance the bill would move forward without amendments. Am I wrong about that too? That’s less and less clear.

Advocates are far from alone in thinking these things. It is widely accepted that most bills in the Texas House this session had to make it out of committee by late April to have any chance to make it to a floor vote in time. Plus, the legislative council, legislative staffers, and influential legislators confirmed that amendments had been drafted and forwarded to committee. Then the bill received a ridiculous fiscal note that inflated the cost of implementation to $1.2 million over five years, with two full-time employees needed to process the several dozen optional contact preference forms that would likely be filed each year. Numerous legislators and legislative staff at the capitol also told us specifically that there was no chance HB2725 would 1) pass without discriminatory amendments; and 2) make it past the May 9 House deadline without amendments having been in the hopper all along. Have they been wrong too? Will HB2725 continue to defy expectations? That’s also less clear at this point.

More specific questions are these: are discriminatory amendments going to be offered by opponents and voted on and approved by the House, in a wink wink way of proving that they were planned all along? Or will the bill just die without consideration by midnight on Thursday, with the Texas Adoptee Rights Coalition having done its part to insist on and assure equality for all Texas adoptees? And will I be wrong again?

My hope is, yes, I’ll be wrong again. I hope that me and TXARC and hundreds of other advocates are wrong about discriminatory amendments. I hope the bill defies expectations again and passes as it is written, with no discriminatory provisions.

In the end, the issue continues to be a fight about what equality means for all adult adopted people. One group, Support Texas Adoptee Rights (STAR), supports discriminatory amendments as a strategy to pass a bill, yet it won’t admit to that. I and many others involved with the Texas Adoptee Rights Coalition do not support backwards-looking inequality, and we are crystal clear and transparent about that, becoming the big meanies on the block for consistently saying so and also backing it up with action.

It’s been a strange process in Texas this session, with brand-new legislators and sponsors, a specific interest from the governor, and a lack of expected transparency from numerous people, including advocates speaking on behalf of adoptees. At this point, I only hope I am wrong again and that HB2725 remains a bill that provides equality for all Texas adoptees. That’s what it is all about.

Filed Under: Latest News Tagged With: HB2725, Texas

Gregory D. Luce

I am a Minnesota lawyer, DC-born adoptee, and the founder of Adoptee Rights Law Center PLLC. I've been practicing law in Minnesota state and federal courts since 1993. I also have a sense of humor.

Get Involved with Adoptees United Inc.

Logo of Adoptees United Inc.Did you find this post interesting? Then get involved nationally with Adoptees United Inc., a national tax-exempt non-profit organization dedicated to securing equality for all adult adopted people in the US. Find out more here, and join me and others in working for equality.

Did I Miss Something?

I work hard to get the laws and facts straight in every state---and to keep them regularly updated. If you see something that's not quite right or doesn't fit your experience, let me know with either a quick comment or an email.

 

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. city says

    May 9, 2019 at 12:06 am

    Is there any chance of ever getting the laws changed to truly equal where certificates are no longer amended at adoption and where access to the riginal would be equal to access by all other citizens meaning it would be a certified version that the person could use for identification purposes, laying the amended one to rest? They have an adoption decree if they need to prove they are adopted.

    We need laws that obligate people with offspring equally and without exemptions for adoption or exemption for any other reason. Exemptions from having to follow the same rules as everyone else obviously compromises the equal protection of those who depend upon having those obligations met.

    I am reluctant to get behind propositions that don’t result in exactly equal treatment because they are easily shot down. At the same time I do know compromise helps some people but that is not real justice.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Adoptee Rights Law Center

The Adoptee Rights Law Center PLLC is an adoptee-focused legal practice founded by Gregory Luce, a Minnesota lawyer and D.C.-born adoptee.

Contact Me

Legal representation limited to issues involving Minnesota law and federal immigration law.

Latest Posts

  • Bill Actions for the First Week of March
  • A Brief History of Florida Adoptee Rights
  • Crunch Week: What You Can Do
  • American Baby and the Punishing Secrecy of Adoption
  • Why I Changed Hawaii’s Status

Contact Info

Adoptee Rights Law Center PLLC
PO Box 19561
Minneapolis Minnesota 55419
T: (612) 221-3947
E: [email protected]

Legal representation limited to issues involving Minnesota law and federal immigration law.

Texas

The Adoptee Rights Law Center is part of the Texas Adoptee Rights Coalition, a coalition of local and national organizations engaged in Texas to change the law and to restore the full right of all adoptees to request and obtain their own original birth certificates.

Join TXARC

The OBC: Numbers

9unrestricted
22compromised
20restricted
51View All

The OBC: Maps

Legislative Tracking

I also monitor federal legislation related to intercountry adoptees.

Footer

Recent Posts

  • Bill Actions for the First Week of March
  • A Brief History of Florida Adoptee Rights
  • Crunch Week: What You Can Do

Contact

Adoptee Rights Law Center PLLC
Gregory D. Luce
PO Box 19561
Minneapolis Minnesota 55419
T: (612) 221-3947
E: [email protected]

Legal representation limited to issues involving Minnesota law and federal immigration law.

Connect

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Vimeo
  • YouTube

New York Adoptee Rights Coalition

Adoptee Rights Law Center is part of the New York Adoptee Rights Coalition, a group of organizations committed to enactment of unrestricted OBC access legislation in New York. Join Us

Copyright © 2021 · Adoptee Rights Law Center PLLC · Home · About · Contact